Cognitive Longevity

Cognitive Testing and Brain Screening:
Who Should Get Tested, and With What

Aevum Protocol9 min read

Brain health testing ranges from a 10-minute pen-and-paper test to brain scans and new blood tests that can detect Alzheimer's-related proteins. More testing isn't always better. For people without symptoms, a major US expert panel found there isn't enough evidence to say whether routine memory screening does more good than harm. For people who have noticed changes in their memory or thinking, though, a proper assessment is worthwhile: it can find treatable causes, give a clearer picture of what's happening, and open the door to support and, in some cases, new treatments. This guide explains the main types of test, what each can and can't tell you, and when testing makes sense for your situation.

Key numbers

FindingDetail
Routine screening of adults 65+ without symptoms (US Preventive Services Task Force, 2020)Insufficient evidence to recommend for or against
MoCA vs. MMSE for detecting mild cognitive impairment (original study, 277 people)MoCA picked up 90%; MMSE picked up 18%
MoCA vs. MMSE for mild Alzheimer's diseaseMoCA 100%; MMSE 78%
Sinhala MoCA for dementia (Sri Lanka, 98 people)Detected 98% of people with Alzheimer's dementia at a cut-off of 24
First FDA-cleared Alzheimer's blood test (May 2025), in people 55+ with symptoms91.7% of positive results confirmed amyloid; 97.3% of negative results confirmed no amyloid
Alzheimer's Association blood-test guideline (2025)For people with cognitive symptoms in specialist care only, and only after a full clinical evaluation

The main types of test

1. Brief cognitive screening tests. These short tests, done in a clinic, check memory, attention, language, orientation and planning.

These are screening tools, not diagnoses. A low score says further assessment is needed; a normal score doesn't rule out early changes.

Grouped bar chart: in mild cognitive impairment, the MMSE picked up 18% and the MoCA 90%; in mild Alzheimer's disease, the MMSE picked up 78% and the MoCA 100% (Nasreddine et al., Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2005)

2. Detailed neuropsychological assessment. A longer assessment, usually by a neuropsychologist, takes one to several hours and tests each area of thinking in depth. It's the best way to characterise subtle changes, distinguish different causes and set a baseline for tracking change over time.

3. Blood tests for treatable causes. When someone has memory problems, standard blood tests look for conditions that can affect thinking and are treatable, such as low vitamin B12 or thyroid problems (see Mild Cognitive Impairment and B Vitamins, Homocysteine, and Brain Aging). A doctor will also review medicines, mood, sleep and hearing, all of which can affect memory.

4. Brain scans.

5. Alzheimer's biomarker tests. These detect the proteins involved in Alzheimer's disease, amyloid and tau, either in spinal fluid (by lumbar puncture) or, more recently, in blood.

In May 2025, the US Food and Drug Administration cleared the first blood test to help diagnose Alzheimer's disease, which measures a form of tau called pTau217 relative to amyloid. It's intended for people aged 55 and over who already have signs and symptoms of cognitive decline, seen in specialist settings. In its validation study of 499 people, 91.7% of those with a positive result had amyloid plaques confirmed by PET or spinal fluid, and 97.3% of those with a negative result didn't. Fewer than 20% got an indeterminate result.

In July 2025, the Alzheimer's Association published its first guideline on these blood tests. It recommends them only for people with objective cognitive impairment being seen in specialist memory care, sets minimum accuracy standards, and states that a blood test shouldn't be ordered before a full clinical evaluation and should always be interpreted alongside it. The guideline doesn't cover primary care or people without symptoms.

6. Genetic tests. APOE testing shows whether you carry a gene variant that raises Alzheimer's risk, but it can't tell you whether you'll develop the disease. The pros and cons are covered in APOE4 and Genetic Risk.

Should you be screened if you have no symptoms?

In 2020, the US Preventive Services Task Force reviewed whether adults aged 65 and over without signs or symptoms should be routinely screened for cognitive impairment. It found the evidence insufficient to judge whether the benefits outweigh the harms. That isn't a recommendation against screening. It means research hasn't yet shown that finding problems early in people without symptoms improves outcomes.

The potential benefits of screening include finding treatable causes, planning ahead, and making lifestyle changes. The potential downsides include anxiety, false-positive results (especially with more sensitive tests like the MoCA), and labelling someone with a problem that may never progress. Blood biomarker tests add another layer: many older people have some amyloid in their brains without ever developing dementia, so a positive result in someone without symptoms can be hard to interpret.

For people without symptoms, the most useful "test" is often a risk-factor check rather than a brain test: blood pressure, blood sugar, cholesterol, hearing, mood, sleep, weight, smoking and physical activity, since these are the things you can act on (see Alzheimer's Disease: Risk Factors You Can Actually Change).

When testing makes sense

Flow diagram, what a memory assessment involves: concern (you or your family notice changes), doctor's review (history, medicines, mood, sleep, hearing), brief tests (cognitive screening and blood tests for treatable causes), brain scan (CT or MRI if needed), and specialist tests (detailed assessment or Alzheimer's biomarkers, in selected cases)

Recommendations by situation

No symptoms, average risk

No symptoms, but worried or strong family history

You've noticed changes yourself

Family members have noticed changes

Mild cognitive impairment already diagnosed

Decision guide, should I get tested: no symptoms, check risk factors, not brain tests; worried or family history, discuss with your doctor, a baseline test is optional; noticed changes, get assessed, many causes are treatable; MCI diagnosed, track change over time and ask about biomarkers

Understanding your results

Cognitive test scores can be affected by many things other than brain disease:

A single score is a snapshot. Change over time, and how you're managing everyday life, often matter more.

Testing in Sri Lanka

Practical notes

Brain testing is most useful when there's a question to answer: when you or your family have noticed changes, or when a diagnosis would change what happens next. For people without symptoms, the evidence doesn't yet support routine screening, and the most valuable step is checking and managing the risk factors you can change. If you do get tested, see it as a starting point: many causes of memory problems are treatable, results need to be interpreted in context, and change over time tells you more than any single score.

References
  1. US Preventive Services Task Force. Screening for Cognitive Impairment in Older Adults: US Preventive Services Task Force Recommendation Statement. JAMA, 2020;323(8):757-763.
  2. Nasreddine ZS, et al. The Montreal Cognitive Assessment, MoCA: A Brief Screening Tool For Mild Cognitive Impairment. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2005;53:695-699.
  3. Karunaratne S, Hanwella R, de Silva V. Validation of the Sinhala version of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment in screening for dementia. Ceylon Medical Journal, 2011;56(4):147-153.
  4. Fujirebio. Lumipulse G pTau217/β-Amyloid 1-42 Plasma Ratio: FDA 510(k) clearance, 16 May 2025. As reported by AJMC (American Journal of Managed Care), May 2025.
  5. Palmqvist S, et al. Alzheimer's Association Clinical Practice Guideline on the use of blood-based biomarkers in the diagnostic workup of suspected Alzheimer's disease within specialized care settings. Alzheimer's & Dementia, 2025.

Have you or your family noticed
any changes in memory or thinking?

Take the free Aevum Protocol assessment to see how your cognitive longevity and 6 other longevity domains are performing — and get a personalised 90-day plan.

Take the Free Assessment →

Related articles