Stress & Hormones

Chronic Stress and Heart Disease:
How the Mind Affects the Heart

Aevum Protocol8 min read

People have long suspected that stress is bad for the heart, and the research backs this up. In INTERHEART, a study of more than 11,000 heart attack patients across 52 countries, people who reported constant stress at work or at home had about twice the odds of a heart attack, and psychosocial factors together accounted for about a third of heart attack risk. Brain-imaging research has traced a possible pathway: activity in the brain's fear centre is linked to inflammation in the arteries and later heart attacks and strokes. But stress needs to be kept in perspective. In a large analysis of European workers, job strain raised heart disease risk by 23%, a real but modest effect compared with smoking or abdominal fat. And psychological treatments for people with heart disease reduced cardiac deaths in trials, though the evidence is of limited quality. This article explains how stress affects the heart, how big the effect is, and what you can do.

Key numbers

FindingDetail
Permanent general stress (INTERHEART, 11,119 heart attack patients and 13,648 controls, 52 countries)About twice the odds of a heart attack (OR 2.17)
All psychosocial factors combined (INTERHEART)About 33% of heart attack risk in the population
Job strain (13 European cohorts, 197,473 workers)23% higher risk of coronary heart disease (HR 1.23)
Share of heart disease attributable to job strain vs. other factorsJob strain 3.4%; by comparison, smoking 36% and abdominal obesity 20% (earlier estimates cited by the same researchers)
Activity in the brain's fear centre (amygdala) and later cardiovascular events (293 people, median 3.7 years)59% higher risk per standard deviation higher activity (HR 1.59)
Psychological treatments in people with heart disease (35 trials, 10,703 people)21% fewer cardiac deaths (RR 0.79); no clear effect on overall deaths; low-quality evidence

Risk factor table: psychosocial stress and heart attack

FactorAssociation (INTERHEART odds of heart attack, unless stated)Modifiable?Evidence strength
Permanent stress at workOR 2.14PartlyModerate (large case-control study)
Permanent stress at homeOR 2.12PartlyModerate (large case-control study)
DepressionOR 1.55Yes: treatableModerate
Major stressful life events in the past yearOR 1.48Rarely, but support helpsModerate
Financial stressOR 1.33PartlyModerate
Job strain (high demands, low control)HR 1.23 for coronary heart diseasePartlyStrong (large pooled cohort analysis)
Horizontal bar chart of the odds of a heart attack with psychosocial stress: permanent general stress 2.17, permanent stress at work 2.14, permanent stress at home 2.12, depression 1.55 and financial stress 1.33, against a line at 1.0 for no extra risk (Rosengren et al., The Lancet, 2004, INTERHEART: 11,119 cases, 13,648 controls, 52 countries)

How stress affects the heart

Stress can affect the heart through several pathways, directly and indirectly.

Direct effects

A brain-to-heart pathway. A 2017 study used brain and body scans to follow 293 people for a median of 3.7 years. People with higher resting activity in the amygdala, the brain region involved in fear and stress, were more likely to have a heart attack, stroke or other cardiovascular event: a 59% higher risk for each standard deviation of higher activity. The researchers traced a chain linking amygdala activity to increased activity in the bone marrow, which produces inflammatory cells, and to inflammation in the arteries, which in turn was linked to later cardiovascular events. In a smaller group of 13 people, higher perceived stress went with higher amygdala activity and arterial inflammation.

This is one of the clearest pictures yet of how stress in the brain might translate into disease in the arteries, though it was a relatively small study with 22 cardiovascular events.

Flow diagram, how stress may reach the heart: stress and amygdala activity, then bone marrow makes more inflammatory cells, then inflammation in the arteries, then heart attack or stroke; each standard deviation higher amygdala activity carried a 59% higher risk of cardiovascular events (Tawakol et al., The Lancet, 2017, 293 people, median 3.7 years)

Indirect effects. Stress also affects the heart through behaviour. People under chronic stress are more likely to smoke, drink more, eat less healthily, sleep poorly, skip exercise and miss medicines. Stress also contributes to abdominal fat and insulin resistance (see Insulin Resistance and Allostatic Load).

What the research shows

Stress is a global heart risk factor. INTERHEART compared 11,119 people who'd had a first heart attack with 13,648 people who hadn't, from 262 centres in Asia, Europe, the Middle East, Africa, Australia and the Americas. People who reported permanent stress, whether at work, at home or in general, had about twice the odds of a heart attack. Financial stress, major life events and depression also raised risk, while a stronger sense of control over one's life was protective. Together, psychosocial factors accounted for an estimated 33% of heart attack risk in the population.

INTERHEART was a case-control study, meaning people reported their stress after their heart attack. That can exaggerate associations, so the true effect may be somewhat smaller.

Work stress: real but modest. A 2012 analysis pooled individual data from 13 European cohort studies with 197,473 workers followed for an average of 7.5 years. About 15% reported job strain, meaning high demands combined with little control. Job strain was linked to a 23% higher risk of coronary heart disease. The researchers estimated that job strain accounted for 3.4% of heart disease cases, far less than the shares previously estimated for smoking (36%) and abdominal obesity (20%).

This matters for perspective. Stress is a genuine heart risk factor, but for most people, not smoking, controlling blood pressure and cholesterol, keeping a healthy waist and staying active have larger effects.

Horizontal bar chart, stress in perspective: share of coronary heart disease linked to each factor, smoking 36%, abdominal obesity 20% and job strain 3.4% (population attributable risk; Kivimäki et al., The Lancet, 2012, 13 European cohorts, 197,473 workers)

Treating psychological stress may help, but the evidence is limited. A 2017 Cochrane review of 35 trials with 10,703 people with coronary heart disease looked at psychological treatments such as stress management, counselling and cognitive behavioural therapy. These treatments reduced cardiac deaths by 21% (RR 0.79) and improved depression, anxiety and stress. However, they didn't clearly reduce overall deaths, heart attacks or the need for heart procedures, and much of the evidence was rated low quality.

What you can actually change

1. Address the conventional risk factors first. Because smoking, high blood pressure, cholesterol, diabetes and abdominal fat have larger effects than stress, they remain the priority. Managing stress often makes these easier to control.

2. Reduce ongoing stress where you can. Look for sources of chronic, uncontrollable stress, at work, at home or financially, and consider what practical changes, support or boundaries might help. A sense of control is protective.

3. Treat depression and anxiety. Depression is a heart risk factor in its own right, and effective treatments exist (see Depression and Cognitive Decline).

4. Build recovery into daily life. Regular exercise, good sleep, time outdoors and relaxation practices help the stress system switch off (see How the Stress Response Works and Stress-Reduction Techniques That Work).

5. Stay connected. Social support buffers stress and is linked to better heart health (see Social Connection and Cognitive Decline).

6. If you have heart disease, ask about cardiac rehabilitation. Cardiac rehabilitation programmes often include exercise, education and psychological support, which can improve mood and quality of life.

Recommendations

Practical notes

Chronic stress contributes to heart disease through raised blood pressure, inflammation, blood clotting, and unhealthy behaviours, and brain-imaging research suggests a direct pathway from the brain's stress centre to inflammation in the arteries. In a global study, constant stress was linked to about twice the odds of a heart attack. At the same time, work stress on its own accounts for a smaller share of heart disease than smoking or abdominal fat. The most effective approach is to manage stress as part of a complete heart-health plan: control the conventional risk factors, reduce ongoing stress, treat depression, stay active and connected, and build daily recovery.

References
  1. Rosengren A, et al. Association of psychosocial risk factors with risk of acute myocardial infarction in 11 119 cases and 13 648 controls from 52 countries (the INTERHEART study): case-control study. The Lancet, 2004;364(9438):953-962.
  2. Kivimäki M, et al. Job strain as a risk factor for coronary heart disease: a collaborative meta-analysis of individual participant data. The Lancet, 2012;380(9852):1491-1497.
  3. Tawakol A, et al. Relation between resting amygdalar activity and cardiovascular events: a longitudinal and cohort study. The Lancet, 2017;389(10071):834-845.
  4. Richards SH, et al. Psychological interventions for coronary heart disease. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2017.

Is constant stress part of
your everyday life right now?

Take the free Aevum Protocol assessment to see how your stress & hormones and 6 other longevity domains are performing — and get a personalised 90-day plan.

Take the Free Assessment →

Related articles